Cost Justification for Automation
Chapter 19 · Part V: Performance and Economics · Source: Lecture 18
19.1 Payback period
This section weighs the financial benefits of automation: the added revenue from increased or improved production is compared with the financial outlay on new equipment or re-tooling. What we want is the time to break even, i.e. when the increased revenue matches the outlay.
\[\text{Added revenue} = \text{Financial outlay}\] \[Nsa(1 + L) = C + Cia + C(u + t)a + Sia\]
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| \(a\) | Payback period (years) |
| \(C\) | Cost of the proposed system |
| \(S\) | Unrecoverable cost of scrapping the old system |
| \(N\) | Number of parts produced per year by the new system |
| \(s\) | Saving per part from changing to the new system |
| \(L\) | Overhead charged against parts (as a fraction) |
| \(i\) | Annual interest rate |
| \(u\) | Annual maintenance cost as a fraction of \(C\) |
| \(t\) | Tax, insurance etc. as a fraction of \(C\) |
Solving for \(a\):
\[\boxed{a = \frac{C}{Ns(1 + L) - Si - C(i + u + t)}}\]
Reading the denominator: annual savings (with overhead) minus the interest on the scrapped asset, minus the annual interest, maintenance, tax and insurance on the new system.
19.2 Example 1
A proposed automated system costs €2.5 million. €50,000 can be recovered from the existing system, whose write-off value is €0.75 million. The new system has a cycle time of 10 + 2 seconds and will run 250 days a year on one 8-hour shift. Marketing require 550,000 units a year. The new system is expected to save €2.25 per part. Overhead charged against the machine is 35%, interest averages 9% a year, tax and insurance combined are 6% of machine cost per year, and maintenance is estimated at €500,000 a year.
Determine the payback period.
- \(S = 0.75 - 0.05 = €0.7\) million
- Capacity: \(\dfrac{250 \times 8 \times 60 \times 60}{10 + 2} = 600{,}000\) units a year, so the 550,000 target can be met. Use \(N = 550{,}000\).
- \(u = \dfrac{500{,}000}{2{,}500{,}000} = 0.2\)
\[a = \frac{2.5 \times 10^6}{550{,}000 \times 2.25 \times 1.35 - 700{,}000 \times 0.09 - 2.5 \times 10^6 \times (0.09 + 0.2 + 0.06)}\]
\[a = \frac{2{,}500{,}000}{1{,}670{,}625 - 63{,}000 - 875{,}000} = \frac{2{,}500{,}000}{732{,}625} = 3.41\ \text{years}\]
After 3.41 years the system starts making a profit for the company.
19.4 Example 2
Marketing estimate that reducing failures will increase sales by 5%, so \(N = 575{,}000\). But the system with improved QC costs €2.75 million. Better quality gives an extra saving of €0.30 per part, but increased overtime payments reduce this by €0.05 per part. Maintenance costs rise by €33,000.
- Saving per part = 2.25 + (0.30 − 0.05) = €2.50
- Total maintenance = €533,000, so \(u = 533{,}000/2{,}750{,}000 = 0.194\)
\[a = \frac{2.75 \times 10^6}{575{,}000 \times 2.5 \times 1.35 - 700{,}000 \times 0.09 - 2.75 \times 10^6 \times (0.09 + 0.194 + 0.06)} = 2.95\ \text{years}\]
The system now breaks even 0.46 years earlier, giving \(0.46 \times 575{,}000 \times 2.5 = €661{,}250\) of extra profit during that time.
Key points
- Payback \(a = C / [Ns(1+L) - Si - C(i+u+t)]\).
- Check capacity first: use the lesser of machine capacity and demand for \(N\).
- Quality improvements can justify a more expensive system through higher sales and lower failure costs.
Interactive applets
Each applet runs in the page; use Open full screen for more room, or open all of this chapter’s applets together.
Applet 19.1 · Payback calculator
Enter or slide every parameter (\(C\), \(S\), \(N\), \(s\), \(L\), \(i\), \(u\), \(t\)); see \(a\) instantly, with a cumulative cash-flow chart that crosses zero at the payback point. Capacity from cycle time and shifts is checked automatically against demand.
Teaches: The formula and its sensitivity. · Open full screen ↗
Applet 19.2 · Tornado sensitivity chart
Vary each input by ±10% and rank which has the biggest effect on payback.
Teaches: Which assumptions matter most (usually \(s\) and \(N\)). · Open full screen ↗
Applet 19.3 · Scenario comparator
Put Example 1 and Example 2 side by side (or the learner’s own scenarios), with the extra profit between break-even points shaded.
Teaches: Quality-related savings, and comparing proposals. · Open full screen ↗
Applet 19.4 · What breaks the deal?
Find the minimum saving per part, or the maximum system cost, that still gives payback within a target (e.g. 3 years); the applet solves inversely.
Teaches: Using the equation for design targets. · Open full screen ↗